The word “anarchy” is synonymous with “chaos”. “Anarchists” are thought to be “bomb throwing criminals”. It seems like unwise branding to continue to use these terms. It’s the reason companies rename themselves because their name may hurt their business.

“Woke” musicians like the former “Dixie Chicks” renamed themselves to “The Chicks” because they thought their name had connotations their fans didn’t like. I think it’s the same kind of thing here.

It immediately puts people on the defensive when they talk about this issue, they’ll say, “I’m an anarchist but not the bomb throwing sort”. The bad reputation of the name is already acknowledged.

It’s the difference between tyranny and “good” monarchy. For the anarchist, maybe they think there is no “good” monarchy. For most people, they’ll recognize there can be some “decent” kings and some bad ones. “Anarchy” just sounds like the “tyranny” version of monarchy. Instead some other term would put a more positive spin on things and be more accurate.

For me, “anarchy” isn’t even accurate. Some of the anarchists say they are for “no gods, no masters”. There is quite a difference between anarcho-communism and anarcho-capitalism. Let the leftist anarchists continue using the term “anarchy” and for people to associate them with criminality. I am ok with some kinds of “anarchy” (like “anarcho-capitalism”?), but it’s a lot more like what we already have than anarcho-communism.

I believe “anarchists” can believe in God and follow hierarchical leadership in private institutions that compete in a market. There may be more freedom to do different things, but we would still end up with a lot of what we see now with policing and enforcement of laws with courts. Taxes may go away, but they would still exist in the form of “fees”, they would just hopefully cost less and be “voluntary” (although a lot of things are pretty much needed in life, so they seem less “voluntary” in a way - it may be “voluntary” for you to choose not to have a subscription to police help, but then you’re kind of exposed to criminals more).

I don’t know what exactly might be good to replace the term “anarchism” with though, maybe that’s up for people to debate about.

Do you think the terms “anarchy”, “anarchist”, or “anarchism” are hurtful or inaccurate or do you think they should be “reclaimed” because “people will just continue to make them in to bad terms so it’s pointless to keep renaming things”?

x0x7
link
fedilink
23M

Maybe “culturalists” as a contrast to “statists”. You believe in society being organized but you believe in achieving that through social norms and self defense rather than force of government.

The problem is not many anarchists are aware of social norms as a tool for keeping social peace, and in fact the main one left when there isn’t a government.

That’s an absolute shot in the dark and I don’t like it. I tried.

Oh, one already exists. Vonluntaryists. We also might adopt Concentists.

c0mmando
link
fedilink
23M

Check out the post we made on this subject: https://blog.hackliberty.org/posts/the-true-meaning-of-anarchy/

@squashkin
creator
link
fedilink
13M

Anarchy literally means ‘Without Rulers’ NOT ‘Without Rules’!

without rulers around, then I think it could also become a situation of being without rules

but it’s also kind of inaccurate because there are still rulers who use self-defensive or market forces to rule by; there definitely can be leaders and authorities

So, what is the golden key to morality? It is very simple, you are a FREE being with INFINITE value that NO ONE has the right to govern.

some people do not make the moral (deontological) but practical (consequentialist) argument for anarchy

Masterofballs
admin
link
fedilink
13M

without rulers around, then I think it could also become a situation of being without rules

The typical example anarchist like to give is language. Languages are formed without any government body and follow a set of naturally created rules.

Its kinda a contrived example but a interesting talking point I think.

Masterofballs
admin
link
fedilink
13M

Nice post

Anarcho-capitalism
!ancap

    The abolishment of the state and nothing else

    • 0 users online
    • 2 users / day
    • 2 users / week
    • 2 users / month
    • 10 users / 6 months
    • 18 subscribers
    • 15 Posts
    • 33 Comments
    • Modlog